I have always been a procrastinator, never more so than when it came to writing school papers. In high school, the night before an essay was due was a frenzy of activity, as I hurried to put together an argument, research and footnotes in one fell swoop. It didn't help that I was a perfectionist, too, especially when it came to writing. Regardless of how little time I'd left myself, I refused to scrimp on quality. I agonized over spelling and content and did my best to deliver an elegant turn of phrase or witty argument whenever possible...and that was the easy part. The hard part came at the end: my father's proofread.
Aside from one's self criticism, one's parents are often the toughest critics. My father was no exception. In fact, given his lifetime devotion to intellectual pursuits, he was tougher than most. This was never more true than when it came to writing. Still, the child in me wanted his approval, knowing if he liked it, it must be good. So, after putting together my last minute masterpieces, I would print them out, find my dad and ask him to look at it.
"Dad, check out my paper on Euthanasia!"
Dad looks up from his newspaper, takes the offered essay, makes himself comfortable and starts reading. I stand there waiting, pride in my work pending parental validation. I know it's good. I just need him to sign off. He reaches the end, grabs a pen and starts over, making occasional marks on my perfect paper. What could he possibly be correcting? Seconds become minutes, ticking away towards his inevitable comment.
"It's a good first draft."
Are you kidding me?!
"Dad, it's due tomorrow."
He hands it back to me and shrugs, the implication clear: "Due tomorrow" should be enough time to get it right. And that was it. No suggestions for how to rephrase or re-word. Just a bunch of extra "that's" crossed out and a bruising blow to the ego. I slink away to my computer to fix it.
I don't think I ever showed him a second draft. One emotional beatdown per paper was more than enough. Truth be told, most of my "first drafts" were good enough to get an "A" in any class. But Dad was bigger than grades. So, I went back to the drawing board and fine-tuned until I felt it would meet his standards, promising myself that next time I would only have to do it once to do it right. His nitpicking propelled me to perfection and, by the time I graduated from college, I was a master at one draft papers. But, no matter how good I got at it, the thought was always in the back of my mind: "It's just a good first draft."
Like writing, if you want to get it right, life is not a one draft process. No matter how disciplined and vigilant you are, there are always things that can be done better, said better. Unnecessary words clutter communication of ideas and even the things we think we are especially good at can be revisited and improved upon. If we're lucky, we start off with a good first draft, but if you're like me, the first run through can be remarkably rough.
It's been over a year since I started the garden. In its own way, it's a one draft A+ paper, especially if you put it in a forgiving context. But we've seen a few beautiful gardens in the last few weeks, Descanso Gardens, the Getty and some enviable personal gardens. Just as I'd never rank my writing with that of the scions of literature or the stars of academia, I don't expect our garden to rival the quality of those gardening masterworks. However, with planting season approaching, I think we could do with a few more edits.
The writing is constantly improving, too. A couple weeks ago, I was finally able to get my dad to read this blog. When my parents visited, I sat him down in front of my computer, told him to read the "I Come to the Garden alone" post and walked away. When I came back, he was crying.
"This is good," he said.
I've waited years for that, but it as far as compliments go, it was as polished a final draft as any I've heard.
Thanks, Dad. I love you. Get better soon, okay?